Phone bans in schools are spreading fast. More than a dozen states have passed laws restricting devices in classrooms, and many individual districts have gone even further. The intent is reasonable — reduce distraction, improve focus, protect mental health.
But for families of students with disabilities, these bans are creating a new and urgent problem: what happens when the device being banned is also the tool your child needs to learn?
When a Phone Ban Becomes a Barrier
Consider a ninth grader named Soraya — a student with dyslexia who started using assistive technology this past school year. Speech-to-text software. Audiobooks. A phone camera to capture notes from the board. The results were dramatic. Straight A’s. A new passion for creative writing.
Then her school introduced a phone ban.
Her IEP specifically permitted her to use her phone for these accommodations. But with multiple teachers across multiple classes, all adjusting to a new policy at the same time, enforcement was inconsistent. Some teachers didn’t know which students were exempt. Others weren’t sure who had authority to make that call.
Soraya’s story isn’t unusual. It’s playing out in schools across the country — and it raises a question every family of a student with a disability needs to be able to answer: does a school’s device policy override an IEP?
The answer is no. And here’s why.
What Assistive Technology Looks Like in Schools
Assistive technology (AT) is any tool — from low-tech to high-tech — that helps a student with a disability access their education more effectively. It covers a wide range:
- Speech-to-text software for students with dyslexia, motor challenges, or physical disabilities
- Text-to-speech and screen readers for students with visual impairments or reading disabilities
- AAC (augmentative and alternative communication) devices for nonverbal students or those with limited speech
- Screen magnification tools for students with low vision
- Health monitoring apps for students managing diabetes or other medical conditions
- Note-taking apps and camera functions for students who can’t write by hand effectively
Many of these tools live on smartphones, tablets, or laptops — the exact devices most school bans are targeting. That’s the collision point.
The Law Is Clear
Federal law doesn’t leave much room for ambiguity here.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), every student’s IEP team is required to consider whether the student needs assistive technology as part of their free appropriate public education. If AT is necessary, the school must provide it — at no cost to the family.
A schoolwide device policy does not override a student’s IEP. Full stop.
Students with accommodations documented in an IEP or a Section 504 Plan have a legal right to use those tools, regardless of what the school’s general policy says. The Americans with Disabilities Act reinforces this further by prohibiting disability-based discrimination in all public school programs.
One thing worth knowing: the words “assistive technology” may not appear verbatim in your child’s plan. Schools often use language like “accommodations,” “supplementary aids and services,” or “program modifications.” The legal protections apply regardless of how it’s worded — what matters is whether the technology is listed as a required part of your child’s program.
What to Do If Your Child’s School Has a Screen Ban
If your child’s school has introduced a device restriction — or you’re concerned one is coming — here are the steps that matter most:
Review the IEP or 504 Plan now. Go through it line by line and identify every device, app, or technology tool listed as an accommodation or required support. If it’s in the plan, it’s protected.
Request an IEP or 504 meeting. You don’t have to wait for the annual review. You can call a meeting at any time. Ask the team to add explicit language stating that your child’s device is exempt from the school’s restriction policy — and to document how staff across all classrooms will be notified.
Get supporting documentation. A letter from your child’s physician, psychologist, or therapist explaining the disability and the specific role the technology plays can strengthen your position. Academic records and progress notes showing improvement with the device are also useful to have.
Put everything in writing. After every conversation with a teacher, administrator, or IEP team member, follow up with an email summarizing what was discussed. Keep copies of all documents — IEPs, evaluations, provider letters, and any communications about accommodations.
Know your escalation options. If the school isn’t honoring your child’s accommodations, you have formal recourse. Options include filing a state compliance complaint with Ohio’s Department of Education, requesting mediation, filing for a due process hearing under IDEA, or submitting a complaint to the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights.
Helpful Resources
- Parent Training and Information Centers (PTI) — Free advocacy support available in every state, including Ohio. Find your local center at parentcenterhub.org
- Assistive Technology Act Programs — State AT programs that offer device lending and consultation at ataporg.org
- Wrightslaw — Plain-language guides on special education law at wrightslaw.com
- Council of Parent Attorneys and Advocates (COPAA) — Legal resources and attorney referrals at copaa.org
- OCR Complaint Portal — File a Section 504 or ADA complaint directly at ed.gov
The Bigger Picture
Screen bans will continue to evolve. Some will be well-implemented. Others won’t. What won’t change is the legal framework that protects students with disabilities — and that framework is only useful if families know it exists and know how to use it.
If your child’s school is enforcing a device ban that’s interfering with their accommodations, that’s not a gray area. It’s a compliance issue. And you have every right to push back.
For families thinking about the longer-term picture — guardianship, special needs trusts, and planning for what happens when a child with a disability reaches adulthood — those are conversations Butcher Elder Law is equipped to help with.
Want to Learn More?
Join us at one of our free upcoming estate planning workshops, where we cover special needs planning, guardianship, and how to build a legal foundation that protects your loved one’s future.
👉 Register at https://butcherelderlaw.com/estate-planning-workshops/ or call 440-268-8284. Seating is limited.